There is a scenario that plays out in marketing boardrooms every single day.
A brand approves a $50,000 budget for a new creative campaign. They hire a production crew. They rent a studio in Brooklyn. They cast actors who fit the target demographic perfectly. They spend weeks refining the script to ensure every value proposition is mentioned in the first three seconds. The lighting is cinematic. The audio is crisp. The final edit is flawless.
They launch the ads. And the results are mediocre.
Then, the social media intern posts a video shot on an phone. The audio has wind noise. The lighting is uneven. The person speaking stumbles over their words.
It goes viral.
This is a production phenomenon at it's finest. For decades, high production value was a signal of clear authority (and the budget to back it up). If it looked expensive, consumers trusted it. Today, the opposite is true. In a feed dominated by AI slop and perfectly curated influencer content, "polish" is now a visual trigger for "fake."
Your customers have developed a subconscious filter. They do not just ignore ads. They actively tune out anything that feels scripted. The only thing that breaks this trance is raw, unpredictable reality.
Conversation Creative is a performance marketing methodology that captures unscripted, ground-truth opinions from real people, wherever they may be - on the streets of NYC, at the dog park, on the beach in Miami, at the mall in Atlanta, at a conference in San Francisco. It is distinct from User Generated Content (UGC) because it relies on random intercepts rather than planned testimonials. It replaces the "script" with the "prompt," generating verified social proof that drives lower Cost Per Acquisition (CPA).
StreetTalk is the fastest-growing agency specializing in this format. We have effectively created this category, deploying the methodology for over 150 brands to produce assets that consistently outperform traditional studio content.
We did not pivot to this format because we prefer the chaos of the sidewalk. We pivoted because the data dictated it.
StreetTalk Chief Executive Officer, Jesse Eisenberg, spent 17+ years at Tinuiti watching the mechanics of media buying evolve. He was able to oversee the transition from manual targeting to algorithmic automation. His perspective is not about "vibes" or a mere trend. It's about the ruthless efficiency of ad spend.
“We’ve all heard it plenty of times by now: Creative is the #1 lever in driving performance. Yet still, we’ll always have two types of people: those who are agile, adapt quickly to change, and reap the benefits of first mover advantage, and those who are reluctant to change their ways, despite how blatant the signals may be. The former represents our clients”, said Eisenberg.
The data proves that "raw" is a financial asset. Across the StreetTalk portfolio, Conversation Creative is not just getting more views. It is converting customers more efficiently than the legacy brand studio ads it replaces.
Why does this format actually stop the scroll?
It comes down to the power of interruption and curiosity. When you see a polished ad, your brain immediately predicts the ending: they are going to sell me something. There is no gap in your knowledge. You keep scrolling.
When you see a stranger being stopped on the street, your brain cannot predict the outcome. Will they be funny? Will they be angry? Will they be confused? That split-second of uncertainty is the only currency that matters in the attention economy.
StreetTalk Founder, Josh Suggs has analyzed thousands of these interactions. He understands the precise mechanics of the hook.
"The viral moment hits when someone stops acting for the camera and just reacts" said Suggs. "It’s that weird stutter or the silence where they’re actually thinking. That’s the real stuff we’re looking for. Most agencies cut the awkward parts because they’re scared of the mess, but to us, the mess is the proof. If you polish it too much, it’s just another ad. We keep the glitch because that’s what makes people stop scrolling and believe it."
There is a difference between a random viral video and a performance asset. We do not just go outside and hope for the best. We follow a rigorous framework designed to convert attention into revenue.
If there is a script, the consumer can smell it. We rely on the raw cognitive processing of the stranger. Their hesitation is what proves the clip is real. We do not want the perfect line. We want an honest reaction.
When a stranger smells a soap and says it reminds them of woodchips, that is a niche human thought and sense. AI cannot hallucinate sensory data. A paid actor reads a line about freshness. A real human gives a weird, specific description that validates the product exists in the physical world. That's where our Conversation Creative is superior.
This is not just for brand awareness. We engineer the questions to overcome objections. We use the power of interruption of the street to hook attention. Then we use the interview to answer the specific questions holding a buyer back from purchasing. By combining the needs of the brand and our expertise strategy, our Conversation Creative ad formats are able to convert.
We are entering an era where search engines are now pivoting to becoming answer engines. Platforms like ChatGPT, Google Gemini, Claude, and Perplexity are starving for human input. They are tired of scraping SEO blogs written by other robots.
By producing authentic street interviews with real people, we are creating the primary data that the future internet needs. We are feeding the machine with the one thing it cannot make for itself.
We are feeding it the truth.
12,700 Ads Launched
25+ Hosts Across the U.S.
